Understanding The Risks Of Private Well Water In America

Approximately 23 million U.S. homes rely on private wells as their primary source of drinking water, but many of these households may be unknowingly consuming contaminated water. This alarming statistic highlights a critical issue that affects countless families across the country. Private wells, while providing a seemingly reliable source of water, often lack the rigorous testing and safety standards that public water systems are required to meet. This oversight can lead to serious health risks, especially when the water is contaminated with substances like nitrates.

In 2022, Gabriel Lade, an associate professor of economics at Macalester College, and a dedicated team of researchers conducted an extensive survey in Iowa to better understand the drinking water behaviors and perceptions of households using private wells. The findings revealed a troubling level of complacency among well owners, who often underestimate the importance of regular water testing. Lade's research not only sheds light on this issue but also calls for more proactive measures to ensure that families are drinking safe water.

Lade noted, "In the U.S. context, there’s quite a few homeowners who use private wells as their main drinking water supply. Anyone who gets water from a public water system can at least rely on the fact that the drinking water coming out of their taps is supposed to meet some minimum quality level." Unfortunately, this is not the case for private well users, who bear the full responsibility for monitoring the safety of their water supply.

Although public health officials recommend annual water testing, the survey found that only 9 percent of households with private wells had tested their water quality in the past year. Even more alarming, 40 percent of well users were drinking water straight from the tap without any recent testing or filtration. The primary contaminant of concern is nitrate, which can enter well water through agricultural runoff, animal waste, and human sewage.

High nitrate levels can lead to serious health problems, including "blue baby syndrome" in infants and long-term risks of conditions such as colorectal cancer and thyroid disease for people of all ages. Moreover, boiling water does not remove nitrates; it only increases their concentration. Surprisingly, 77 percent of surveyed households classified their well water quality as "good" or "great," despite living in high-risk areas.

"There are certain types of pollutants where the water will smell fine, it’ll look clear, it tastes fine, yet it’s unsafe for human consumption," Lade explained. This misunderstanding can be dangerous, as many families believe their water is safe simply because it appears clean.

The survey also revealed a potential solution: providing information and easy-to-use testing materials significantly increased testing rates. When households received a simple mailer containing a nitrate test strip and educational information, over 40 percent reported testing their water, compared with just 24 percent of those who didn’t receive the mailer.

"What we found is that testing rates went up," Lade stated. "Self-reported testing rates went way up, and even testing rates of the free county program went up too." Still, the burden of dealing with contaminated water largely falls on individual households. While some states—like Iowa—offer free or low-cost testing kits, many rural residents face significant financial obstacles in ensuring their water is safe.

"This kind of shows that there’s value to programs that just provide people basic information about the importance of testing your private well," Lade said. As climate change threatens to exacerbate nitrate contamination through increased heavy rainfall, there is an urgent need for a reevaluation of agricultural policies as well as improved support for affected households.

Do you have a tip on a science story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have a question about drinking water? Let us know via science@newsweek.com.

References

Lade, G.E., Comito, J., Benning, J., Keiser, D., & Kling, C. (2022). The Iowa Rural Drinking Water Survey: Water Quality Perceptions and Avoidance Behaviors Among Rural Iowa Households.