Carb lover, have you tried the cracker test? OutInCanberra

The Cracker Test: Can You Eat Carbs Without Gaining Weight?

Carb lover, have you tried the cracker test? OutInCanberra

Eating carbs makes you fat and sick. Case closed. Or at least that's what the most popular diets of the past few decades have told us. But the reality is a little more complicated. Carbohydrates, which are essential for our bodies, are often misunderstood. It’s time to explore the intricacies of carb consumption, and how the "cracker test" offers insights into our individual carbohydrate tolerance.

Carbohydrates fall into three main categories: starch, sugar, and fiber. Foods from milk to kale and potatoes contain these essential molecules that provide energy. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends that we choose carbohydrates that are lower in calories, fat, and sugar, yet higher in water, fiber, vitamins, and minerals. This means opting for a stewed apple pie sprinkled with cinnamon instead of a doughy apple pie.

Recently, the cracker test has gained attention, particularly after being featured on the BBC TV show The Truth About Carbs. Developed by Dr. Sharon Moalem, a U.S.-based geneticist, this test aims to determine how many starchy carbohydrates a person can consume without gaining excess weight. By chewing on plain, unsalted crackers and timing the flavor change, individuals can assess their carbohydrate digestion capabilities.

What You Will Learn

  • The cracker test helps assess individual carbohydrate tolerance.
  • Carbohydrates are essential for energy and fall into three categories.
  • The CDC recommends choosing carbs that are nutrient-rich.
  • Your ability to digest carbs is linked to genetics and enzyme levels.

The cracker test involves taking three plain, unsalted crackers and timing how long it takes for them to change flavor while chewing. According to Dr. Moalem, the speed of flavor change can categorize individuals into three groups: full, moderate, or restricted carb intake. This classification is primarily influenced by the concentration of amylase, an enzyme that assists in starch digestion.

If someone detects a flavor change within 14 seconds, they likely have a high level of amylase, suggesting that they can incorporate more carbs into their diet—up to 50 percent of their daily caloric intake. Those who take 15 to 30 seconds fall into the moderate category and should limit their carb intake to 35 percent of their daily calories. If the timer exceeds 30 seconds, then carb consumption should be restricted to about 25 percent of daily calories.

Critics of the cracker test, including qualified dietitian Aisling Pigott, argue that there is no definitive test for carbohydrate processing. The digestion of carbohydrates is a complex process influenced by various factors, and individuals respond differently. While the cracker test may provide insights, it's crucial to remember that carbohydrates are important for our energy needs and should not be entirely demonized.

Ultimately, understanding how our bodies react to carbohydrates can help us make informed dietary choices. By recognizing our unique digestion capabilities, we can better manage our diets and overall health.

This piece was updated to include comments from Aisling Pigott.

pasta-spaghetti-meatballs-stock
Moalem believes people who can break down starchy carbs quickly have ancestors who subsisted mainly on grains.Getty Images

Unlocking The Secrets Of Wordle: A Guide To Mastering The Daily Puzzle
Unpacking The Will Smith And Chris Rock Oscars Incident: A Year Later
Anne Heche And Ellen DeGeneres: A Love Story That Captivated Hollywood

Carb lover, have you tried the cracker test? OutInCanberra
Carb lover, have you tried the cracker test? OutInCanberra
The Dr Oz 30 Second Cracker Test DrOz Health Carbs YouTube
The Dr Oz 30 Second Cracker Test DrOz Health Carbs YouTube
Edge of WellnessCan The Cracker Test Really Tell you how Many Carbs you
Edge of WellnessCan The Cracker Test Really Tell you how Many Carbs you